ACT-Asia

Monday, October 23, 2006

Skype Session - 24 Oct 2006

Hey everybody, I've uploaded the recording of our Skype session with Ron. Sorry it's only a one way communication recording at the momento (Ron to us). The technical team still have some bugs to fix. It's a work in progress.

Update 9 Nov 2006:
I've uploaded the file to zupload.com. It's a free file hosting website. To download the file, visit:
http://z33.zupload.com/download.php?file=getfile&filepath=114


Once there, you'll see a bunch of Google Ads, but when you look carefully at the top-left of the section where the ads are (and below the zupload.com logo), you should see a prominent link that says "Download File". Click it, and voila! Download will begin.

The file is password protected. The password is "ACT-Asia" (case sensitive, without the quotes). Best way to get the password right, is to copy-paste.

Any questions, or comments, please post in the comment(s) section below.


Regards,

Eugene.

Thursday, October 19, 2006

Questions for Session 3 - Plato's World of Forms (23/10/06)

1. The name of Plato’s craftsman is the Demiurge. He is known as the maker of the things of the universe. Some early Christians thought Plato might be referring to Jesus. Why do you think they did not think Plato was referring to God himself?

2. What does it mean when I write that Plato’s thoughts on his “likely story” came from observation rather than revelation?

3. Why are the religions of Hinduism and Buddhism not revelatory? They have their own holy scriptures, the Vedas, the Gita, the Ramayana, and the Pali Canon, among others. What makes any scriptures revelatory?

4. Read the first few pages of Allen’s chapter 2 (p39-45) and write out a brief definition of the soul according to Plato. What is the relationship between beauty and memory according to Plato?

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

Answers to questions from Session 2

Question 1
What is the correct interpretation of Augustine's concept of time? One of the members who read Confessions did not agree with Allen's view that time was created alongside all other creation (page 23, second paragraph).

A proper way to raise this question is to ask the member to provide the specific reference in Confessions, chapter 11 and the quote so that a good argument can be advanced to challenge Allen’s reading of Augustine. This is an exercise in doing good philosophy. Then have the person say why he disagrees with Allen.

Question 2
In your manual concerning the Trinity, how is the substance and will related? Are they the same? Is it becuase the Trinity is of one substance that they are of one will?

Substance refers to the stuff of things. Will refers to the intention. When we say God in the Trinity is of the same substance, we mean that all three are made of the stuff that Gods are made of. They are divine. When we say that they have the same will, we are referring not to a single volition, but 3 volitions that appear as one because they are in agreement. How do we know there is more than one volition? Because Jesus answered that while the Father knows what will happen in the future, he does not. At the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus prayed that the cup be taken away from him BUT he will agree with the Father about what he should do. Warning: Do not use Gen 1 “Let us ...” to make the case for the Trinity. THAT does not refer to the Trinity but to God speaking to the heavenly Council.

Question 3
Did the concept of the Trinity always exist in the early Christian Community and the various councils just ratified it?

The concept of the Trinity did not exist until the councils started debating it and was not fully affirmed until the 5th century at the fourth council.

Question 4
Did Jesus still have a common will when He was on earth?

Yes, he answered Philip on this that to see Jesus is the same as to meet God. Yet, in his humanity, his knowledge was limited – this affected the expression of his will.

Question 5

Why was there an internal struggle in the Garden of Gethsemene if Jesus had a common will?

This was his humanity in expression. You will notice that he finally agreed with the Father's will.

Thursday, October 05, 2006

Session 2 (09/10/2006) Questions

From the ACT manual:
Ch2:
What is the difference between a common and a shared will? (think of the notion of adoption)

Ch3:
Discuss the analogies of the sun, the line and the cave mentioned in the Republic. Make sure everyone understands the meaning. Consider the journey from illusion to reality (page 14).
Does this remind anyone about the claims of Hinduism and Buddhism regarding what is real and what is illusory?
How does the Timeaus (page 15) contribute to a Christian understanding of creation?
Why cant we prove divine revelation?

From Philosophy for Understanding Theology:
What does the Timaeus teach about the source of true morality (page 16)?
If the source is not by convention or human will, how can we know what the standard of morality should be?

How is Platos story of the origin of the universe different from that of the Bibles (page 19)?
Does Platos universe have a beginning (page 22)?
Does Plato even have a proper creation story, according to Allen and why (page 24) ?

Who adapted Platos Timaeus for Christian use (page 25)?

In your own words, paraphrase Platos “likely story” (page 27).

Why does Allen believe that philosophical reflection on the order of the universe is of interest to theology (page 37)?