Session 9 (05/02/07) Questions
Readings:Philosophy for Understanding Theology, Diogenes Allen, Ch. 5
Greek Philosophy in Christian Doctrines, Ron Choong, Chapters 10 and 11
Aristotle’s Causes
See Allen’s book, p121-125 on the 4 causes (start with the second paragraph of p121 and you will find specific reference to the 4 causes at the bottom of p124) and then read ACT manual. ch 10, p31ff. Also refer to ch. 4 of Peter Hick’s book to remind yourself of the big picture of Aristotle’s thought. Do not despair if at the beginning it all feels too much – it IS too much. But bit by bit, you can do it. No one is going to know how quickly you got it, just go get it. The majority of philosophy students study, understand, memorize, take exams and then promptly forget what they thought they knew or understood. This is normal. But if you study it for a theological and spiritual reason, you have an advantage. Your passion to know transcends sheer knowledge so use it whenever you can.
Aristotle distinguished between natural and artificial things. In his explanation, change takes place as potential becomes actual. Among natural things, a child grows, a seed planted becomes a tree, etc., so that material cause become formal cause. Flesh becomes bigger flesh. Seed become tree. But artificial things become what they are because the maker intends it – this is the telos, or end of the final form. A brick is intended by the brickmaker (efficient cause) who takes clay and stuff (material cause), shaped into brick shapes (formal cause) and finally used to build a house (final cause)
Q1. What do we mean when we say that God is pure act and has no potency?
Q2. How did the Christian description of God as eternal and reliable become the teaching that God does not change? (Yesterday, today, forever, Jesus is the same)
Q3. Can God change and yet be trusted? Think about God repenting, regretting, changing his mind about Nineveh. God almost changed his mind about Sodom and Gomorrah.
