Discussion Questions fro chapter 5 of the ACT manual: The SOUL (This exercise seeks to identify the influence of Plato’s soul on early Christian thought and how we ought to distinguish the Christian idea of the soul from the secular notion)
Question 1Plato’s concept of love has no divine lover (p19). In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, the monster created by Dr. Frankenstein became violent and killed the people whom his maker loved. When asked why, he said, “Thou makest me and yet thou lovest me not.” Dr Frankenstein could not bring himself, a London society gentleman, to be near the foul-smelling ugly creature he created, mostly from garbage and body parts from the morgue. Consider how the Christian God made us and in spite of our sinfulness, he loves us and goes after us even when we turn away. John Stott calls God the hound of heaven, who keeps after us until we relent and trust Jesus. In what way is the Christian soul aimless until it finds rest in God?
Question 2Plato speaks of the soul as intelligence (the charioteer, or car driver) having to constantly control and manage his appetites (the two horses each going a different way, or the steering of his SUV). 1600 years after Plato, the Medieval Franciscan monk John Duns Scotus developed this idea and named the two appetites desires for personal advantage and for justice. Both are good and proper in their own contexts. But what happens when they are in conflict? Think of real life situations when your desire to benefit yourself (job, car parking space, food, housing, etc.) conflicts with doing the right thing before God’s eyes (exploiting others, lying, withholding truth, white lies, etc.) Here, the soul takes on a moral role. Can you see why the Buddha recognized the significance of human desires that are not controlled? Gautama was a contemporary of Plato but born in what is now Nepal. Some historians believe that both were influenced by Hindu philosophies from what is now Pakistan. What was the Buddha's answer to controlling unbridled passions? How does it compare with Plato's and with Christianity's?
Question 3We are all driven by the quest for beauty because beauty satisfies our soul. The Christian desire for earthly beauty reflects our hard-wiring to seek the beauty of God. Have you noticed how even very young children learn to recognize things of beauty? Little girls love to dress up and be noticed and little boys (with their own sense of beauty) desire to be acknowledged for their own achievements and abilities? The Christian should not be ashamed of achievement and desire for excellence. Mediocrity is the enemy of excellence. But the danger is that our quest (appetites) for excellence, if not tamed by a charioteer of conscience (the soul who seeks justice above even personal advantage), can result in great suffering for others who we are wont to exploit. In a world of unequal opportunities and great selfishness, what is the call of the Christian to be different? Consider some practical ways to shape your thinking at work and at home about what it means to be just while seeking excellence in all things