Session 7 (18/12/2006) Questions
THE PLATONIC TRADITION
As we move to consider the thinkers and their thoughts following Plato, we encounter folks such as the Stoics, Plotinus the philosopher and the mysterious Pseudo-Dionysius.
It was Socrates who transformed philosophy from a study of nature to a consideration of the human soul. His student, Plato, claimed that humans are both material and immaterial – we possess souls. We are to be mindful fo the afterlife, and prepare for the permanent existence apart form our biological one. Does this find any echoes any of the NT teachings by Jesus and Paul?
Plato further said that only our acts of injustice can damage our souls, so he set out to investigate the nature of justice so we can learn to live a just life for the sake of our souls. This means that the most dangerous harm to ourselves is moral and not mortal injury. Read Matt. 10:28 for a Christian variation.
After Plato’s death in 348 B.C., it took another 250 years before his ideas once gained currency once more.
Plato also developed the idea of the polis – the life of a citizen in a city-state. But this concept collapsed with the wars and fighting among the citizens. The result was a philosophical reaction against such idealism.
Q1. Compare the Cynics, the Stoics, and the Epicureans. How are they similar to, and how are they different from each other?
Q2. How did Greek Stoicism different from Roman Stoicism?
Q3. Why would a Stoic not agree with Plato that ‘This world is not my home?’
Answer: For the simple reason that the Stoics believe that there is but one glorious life and this is ‘as good as it gets’, so to speak. Plato believed that we are created as copies of the Forms, and there exists a higher world of the Demiurge and the perfect Forms, while the Stoics maintained that this world is good as a whole and in every detail of it’s operation. The universe is guided by a single principle that is rational and immanent, manifests as organism in plants, appetites in animals and reason in people.
Simon Yoong
Well after the deaths of Plato and Aristotle, from around 100 B.C. Till around 200 A.D., a philosophical movement now called Middle Platonism arose. Their most famous philosopher was Plotinus. They conceptualized the notion of The Supreme Mind. why do we care about them? Because they were the philosophical bridge between Plato and Aristotle. Their thoughts about the soul having come from and perhaps having fallen from another realm influenced Augustine, who greatly influenced the way Christians interpreted the Hebrew scriptures.
Q4. Who were the Middle Platonists? What were they trying to achieve by reconciling the ideas of Plato (the Forms) and Aristotle (the unmoved mover)?
Middle Platonism refers to the development of certain philosophical doctrines associated with Plato from approximately 130 BC (the birth of Antiochus of Ascalon) up to and including late 2nd century Numenius of Apamea. Plotinus is thought to have inaugurated the next Platonic school of Neoplatonism.
What were they trying to achieve by reconciling the ideas of Plato (the Forms) and Aristotle (the unmoved mover)?
By reconciling the ideas of Plato and Aristotle, the Middle Platonists were trying to establish the Supreme Mind and
The Middle Platonist took from Plato the Form of Good and identified it with Supreme Mind. They also took from Aristotle some of the features of unmoved mover and applied them to their Supreme Mind. Although the texts I researched did not explicitly indicate their intentions for reconciling both Plato and Aristotle's ideas, I think they helped to shape our thinking on the Supremacy and Transcedence of God.
LArry
Q5. How did the word Logos move from its philosophical usage to its theological usage by Christians with the New Testament?
Read how the Middle Platonists changed Plato’s ideas a bit and Philo the Jew further changed the meaning of the terms so that now Logos means the Forms, even though Plato himself never made this connection. By the time it reached the Gospel according to John, the Logos now referred to Jesus.
The Platonic revival started in 100 B.C., but underwent a new phase, now called Late Neoplatonism, to distinguish it from the Middle Platonism of Plotinus.
Q6. According to Pseudo-Dionysius, how can we know God? Read p90ff.
In the tradition of Plato, reason is believed to be sufficient to know of the existence as well as the nature of God.
Pseudo-Dionysius works out two ways to know God from knowledge of God’s creatures – the positive way and the negative way:
The positive way - the affirmative theology: all names, as far as they are positive, must be attributed to God because He is the Ground of everything; so He is designated by everything, everything points to Him. God can be named with all names that are positive (e.g. wisdom, life, goodness).
The negative theology denies that He can be named by anything whatsoever. He is even beyond the highest names theology has given to Him. He is beyond spirit. He is beyond the good. He is super-essential, beyond essences, super-exalted, i. e., beyond all superlatives. He is not the highest being but beyond any possible highest being; and He is super-Divinity. He is beyond God, if we speak of God as a Divine being.
However, in both cases – the positive and the negative way, we would come to a conclusion that God in essence is unknowable. Therefore He is "Divine Darkness". What we learn of God from creatures cannot be applied to God, as by His very nature, He denies the possibility that He can be seen or can be spoken of.
Therefore all names disappear, after they have been attributed to Him, even the holy name "God." He is "the God above God," - above any special name we can give, even to a highest being.
Accordingly, this is a positive state and not a failure of the intellect. Not relying on our intellect but by yielding them, we would be able to encounter God who comes to meet us.
Stephen
Q7. What have you learned about how the Platonic tradition so strongly influenced New Testament ideas and expressions?
This is how I think the Platonic tradition influenced New Testament ideas: Where there were similarities, the idea was adopted, added to, or reworded as necessary to express what the New Testament people were trying to describe. For example, the idea of “the Demiurge” was modified somewhat to describe “Creator God”. Almost similar ideas, but not totally: the Demiurge follows blueprints, Creator God does not. But both “make things”.
From that, what I learned was that we shouldn’t reject any thought outright but see if there’s common ground where we could discuss things. This is important when trying to reach out to non-Christians. Rather than pin-pointing that they are wrong wrong wrong, I think we should try to find ideas that we’re in agreement with first, and where we disagree, we explain our point of view.
Eugene
As we move to consider the thinkers and their thoughts following Plato, we encounter folks such as the Stoics, Plotinus the philosopher and the mysterious Pseudo-Dionysius.
It was Socrates who transformed philosophy from a study of nature to a consideration of the human soul. His student, Plato, claimed that humans are both material and immaterial – we possess souls. We are to be mindful fo the afterlife, and prepare for the permanent existence apart form our biological one. Does this find any echoes any of the NT teachings by Jesus and Paul?
Plato further said that only our acts of injustice can damage our souls, so he set out to investigate the nature of justice so we can learn to live a just life for the sake of our souls. This means that the most dangerous harm to ourselves is moral and not mortal injury. Read Matt. 10:28 for a Christian variation.
After Plato’s death in 348 B.C., it took another 250 years before his ideas once gained currency once more.
Plato also developed the idea of the polis – the life of a citizen in a city-state. But this concept collapsed with the wars and fighting among the citizens. The result was a philosophical reaction against such idealism.
Q1. Compare the Cynics, the Stoics, and the Epicureans. How are they similar to, and how are they different from each other?
Q2. How did Greek Stoicism different from Roman Stoicism?
Q3. Why would a Stoic not agree with Plato that ‘This world is not my home?’
Answer: For the simple reason that the Stoics believe that there is but one glorious life and this is ‘as good as it gets’, so to speak. Plato believed that we are created as copies of the Forms, and there exists a higher world of the Demiurge and the perfect Forms, while the Stoics maintained that this world is good as a whole and in every detail of it’s operation. The universe is guided by a single principle that is rational and immanent, manifests as organism in plants, appetites in animals and reason in people.
Simon Yoong
Well after the deaths of Plato and Aristotle, from around 100 B.C. Till around 200 A.D., a philosophical movement now called Middle Platonism arose. Their most famous philosopher was Plotinus. They conceptualized the notion of The Supreme Mind. why do we care about them? Because they were the philosophical bridge between Plato and Aristotle. Their thoughts about the soul having come from and perhaps having fallen from another realm influenced Augustine, who greatly influenced the way Christians interpreted the Hebrew scriptures.
Q4. Who were the Middle Platonists? What were they trying to achieve by reconciling the ideas of Plato (the Forms) and Aristotle (the unmoved mover)?
Middle Platonism refers to the development of certain philosophical doctrines associated with Plato from approximately 130 BC (the birth of Antiochus of Ascalon) up to and including late 2nd century Numenius of Apamea. Plotinus is thought to have inaugurated the next Platonic school of Neoplatonism.
What were they trying to achieve by reconciling the ideas of Plato (the Forms) and Aristotle (the unmoved mover)?
By reconciling the ideas of Plato and Aristotle, the Middle Platonists were trying to establish the Supreme Mind and
The Middle Platonist took from Plato the Form of Good and identified it with Supreme Mind. They also took from Aristotle some of the features of unmoved mover and applied them to their Supreme Mind. Although the texts I researched did not explicitly indicate their intentions for reconciling both Plato and Aristotle's ideas, I think they helped to shape our thinking on the Supremacy and Transcedence of God.
LArry
Q5. How did the word Logos move from its philosophical usage to its theological usage by Christians with the New Testament?
Read how the Middle Platonists changed Plato’s ideas a bit and Philo the Jew further changed the meaning of the terms so that now Logos means the Forms, even though Plato himself never made this connection. By the time it reached the Gospel according to John, the Logos now referred to Jesus.
The Platonic revival started in 100 B.C., but underwent a new phase, now called Late Neoplatonism, to distinguish it from the Middle Platonism of Plotinus.
Q6. According to Pseudo-Dionysius, how can we know God? Read p90ff.
In the tradition of Plato, reason is believed to be sufficient to know of the existence as well as the nature of God.
Pseudo-Dionysius works out two ways to know God from knowledge of God’s creatures – the positive way and the negative way:
The positive way - the affirmative theology: all names, as far as they are positive, must be attributed to God because He is the Ground of everything; so He is designated by everything, everything points to Him. God can be named with all names that are positive (e.g. wisdom, life, goodness).
The negative theology denies that He can be named by anything whatsoever. He is even beyond the highest names theology has given to Him. He is beyond spirit. He is beyond the good. He is super-essential, beyond essences, super-exalted, i. e., beyond all superlatives. He is not the highest being but beyond any possible highest being; and He is super-Divinity. He is beyond God, if we speak of God as a Divine being.
However, in both cases – the positive and the negative way, we would come to a conclusion that God in essence is unknowable. Therefore He is "Divine Darkness". What we learn of God from creatures cannot be applied to God, as by His very nature, He denies the possibility that He can be seen or can be spoken of.
Therefore all names disappear, after they have been attributed to Him, even the holy name "God." He is "the God above God," - above any special name we can give, even to a highest being.
Accordingly, this is a positive state and not a failure of the intellect. Not relying on our intellect but by yielding them, we would be able to encounter God who comes to meet us.
Stephen
Q7. What have you learned about how the Platonic tradition so strongly influenced New Testament ideas and expressions?
This is how I think the Platonic tradition influenced New Testament ideas: Where there were similarities, the idea was adopted, added to, or reworded as necessary to express what the New Testament people were trying to describe. For example, the idea of “the Demiurge” was modified somewhat to describe “Creator God”. Almost similar ideas, but not totally: the Demiurge follows blueprints, Creator God does not. But both “make things”.
From that, what I learned was that we shouldn’t reject any thought outright but see if there’s common ground where we could discuss things. This is important when trying to reach out to non-Christians. Rather than pin-pointing that they are wrong wrong wrong, I think we should try to find ideas that we’re in agreement with first, and where we disagree, we explain our point of view.
Eugene
