Aristotle’s Categories and the Mystery of GodQ1. Explain what substances mean in Aristotle’s system of thought. How would you distinguish primary from secondary substances? Why do you think this distinction was important for Aristotle?
Primary substance: A specific unique object e.g. = GordonSecondary substances: A group of "specific unique obejects" which share similar qualities.e.g. = Human Being (Gordon, Ron, Stephen, Larry are human beings)Aristotle was trying to categorize and distinguish everything so that people would have a clear idea of who/what they were referring to when dicussing a particular subject/object.
Gordon
Q2. What did Aristotle mean by accidents? How is essence distinguished from accidents? Give an example of a chosen item in the world and identify its 2 substances and 9 accidents.
Part 1: Accidental are things that changes. for eg height, weight, an action or place . it is a space and action that is occupy by someone which no other person can be at the same time.
Chai Yen
Part 2:
Substance: I’m Eugene (primary), and I’m human (secondary)
Accidents:
There’s only one of me (quantity), and I’m a curious person (quality). I’m Andrew Ng’s son (relation), and I’m typing my answer to question 8 (action). The air from the air-conditioner is cooling me down (being acted on). I’m sitting on a chair (posture), having a watch on my left wrist (having). I’m at home (place) at 19:17 – 24 January 2007 (time).
EugeneQ3. According to Dr. Allen, how can we know if we are to labor or to give up our quest to understand God? When should we properly answer a theological question with “the ‘hiddenness of God’ or the ‘mystery of the divine being’”? (p101)
Answer: According to Dr. Allen, we are to labour because God shows part of His nature through His operations and although we cannot fully understand His nature from it due to our lack of concept or models, it is sometimes even tentative and speculative in nature, it however casts no doubt upon the truth of what has been revealed and is religiously rewarding. We should only used the terms ‘hiddenness of God’ or the ‘mystery of the divine being’ in answering theological questions when the truth is truly beyond our capacity to understand and that we can finally ascribe ignorance to the mystery. But only when we have exhausted all our avenues to understand it by studying and rational thought, and truly accept that it is beyond our intellect.
Simon Yoong
Q4. What does “faith seeking understanding” mean in St Augustine’s reflections? (p102)
How Gregory of Nyssa adapted Greek philosophy for Christian doctrineQ5. How exactly did Bishop Gregory choose to adopt and then adapt the concept of ousia (substance) to explain the concept of the divine Trinity?
Mia ousia, treis hypostaseis – “One substance, three persons” is used to describe the divine Trinity
Gregory differentiates between ousia and hypostasis by using the example of man ie Andrew, John or James, who have the same essence of humanity but at the same time has different properties as individuals. The way one is differentiated or distinguished from another is called the hypostasis.
Ousia = essence or substance and is likened to Aristotle’s secondary substance, also referred to as species (deutra ousia)
Hypostasis = individuals and is likened to Aristotle’s primary substance (prote ousia)
But then Gregory goes on to say that the way we use hypostasis and ousia for people is only an anology for their proper use for the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The ousia of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit do not have the same ousia, they are the same ousia. They are one ousia because they are one God.
Emilia Lim
Q6. What are the pros and cons of the way the terms were used? How can it be misunderstood by us today? Give an example.